Whakaari Management Limited Conviction Overturned

In previous editions of Commercial eSpeaking, we have reported on the conviction and sentencing of Whakaari Management Limited (WML). The District Court convicted WML under section 37 of the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 for failing to ensure the safety of tourists visiting Whakaari/White Island following its December 2019 eruption that killed 22 people and severely injured 25 more.

Section 37 imposes a duty on those who manage or control a workplace to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that their workplace is without risks to the health and safety of any person.

The High Court has since overturned WML’s conviction. Central to this decision was the interpretation of ‘management or control of the workplace.’ WML’s role was limited to granting access to Whakaari – it did not actively direct or oversee activities on the island. This lack of operational control meant WML did not manage or control the workplace in the sense contemplated by section 37.

The High Court found that the risk of people being on Whakaari during an eruption stemmed from the work activity controlled by the tour operators, not WML’s business operations. WML had imposed health and safety obligations on the tour operators and relied on regulatory guidance in respect of the risk. As a result, the High Court was satisfied that, even if section 37 had been triggered, WML had taken all reasonable steps to discharge such a duty.

Although this decision may be a relief to many business owners, we urge continued caution. Neglecting to exercise power or control does not exempt a business from its duty under section 37. A practical and fact-specific exercise should be undertaken to assess whether the business can actively control or manage the workplace. Businesses must continue to identify circumstances where a duty may be owed and ensure appropriate steps are taken to discharge this.

DISCLAIMER: All the information published is true and accurate to the best of the authors’ knowledge. It should not be a substitute for legal advice. No liability is assumed by the authors or publisher for losses suffered by any person or organisation relying directly or indirectly on this article. Views expressed are those of individual authors, and do not necessarily reflect the view of this firm. Articles appearing in this newsletter may be reproduced with prior approval from the editor and credit given to the source. Copyright, NZ LAW Limited, 2019. Editor: Adrienne Olsen. E-mail: adrienne@adroite.co.nz. Ph: 029 286 3650 or 04 496 5513.